Joselin appeared on several episodes Scrubs, where Judy’s no-nonsense Nurse Carla ruled the roost, but otherwise the Bronx-born actresses have kept to their own projects–most recently P-ValleyJoselin Take it one day at a time And Search Party Judy.

Judy explained to Shondaland, “It wasn’t my twin sister that wanted to act,” Judy said in 2018. She made her mom go to acting classes. My mom was so mad that she forced her to go, and the man demanded $150 for photos.

Joselin received a master’s of social work, while Judy was not sure about her future until she was in her teen years. It was a “click” moment for her, she said. Smashing Interviews MagazineIn 2011.

Asked if anyone ever had a hard time telling her and Joselin apart when they were kids, Judy shared, “No, we’re actually fraternal twins. As we enter our fourth decade, it seems that we have a tendency to be more alike than we were in fifth grade. So, they weren’t “that lucky” to be able to play pranks like identical twins could, “but maybe that’s why we became actresses.”