Interview with HuffPost Live January 2015, more than six years after her first date. Aaron Rodgers, Olivia recalled being at a wedding with John and his then-fiancée, Anna Marie Tendler, saying, “and I was like, ‘Oh my gosh, do you and your fiancèe want to go have dinner or something and go hang out?” John and Anna got married in 2014.

Olivia stated that Olivia kept coming up to him during the wedding. She also added that “I was just so obsessed about hanging out with him and talking with him.”

According to the actress, she sent John another email and he didn’t reply. “I might’ve got the wrong email—probably,” she told HuffPost Live. That’s all I say to myself.