Prior to getting together with his girlfriend of a while, Summer House‘s Paige DeSorboCraig was a gf Natalie Hegnauer. And like his relationship with Naomie, an argument between the two—involving cast member Madison LeCroy—put the nail in the coffin of their romance. Madison, Craig’s co-star and castmate had an infamously complicated and eventually fatal relationship with Craig’s friend. Austen Kroll.)

“When I quit to film” Winter HouseIn January 2021 we were still together and, despite the rumors of me seeing Paige DeSorbo in January, there was no separation. “I was still upset that Madison had been to dinner with Madison when I was filming here in Vermont. Natalie had known my feelings about Austen.” he wrote.

We both realized that this relationship didn’t work after I came back. We both realized that what had occurred during quarantine couldn’t continue in real life, which is a shame, but I’m not regretful.