This couple did not get their “happily ever thereafter” as they hoped.

The second season of Netflix’s reality dating seriesBlind Love—hosted by Vanessa and Nick LacheyKyle AbramsAnd Shaina Hurley immediately hit it off in the pods. But once they started talking about their religious views, things started to get a bit rocky,And it was a roller coaster from there. The pair eventually got engaged, broke it off in Mexico, got back together in Chicago, before breaking up for a final time after Kyle met Shaina’s parents.

In an exclusive CelebHomes News interview, Kyle and Shaina discussed whether they think they could have made it work, despite religious differences. 

Kyle is an Atheist, and has never considered Shaina’s Christian faith an issue. He believes that the two could have come to an agreement. Kyle said that they felt like they had moved past the issue in the beginning. After learning about her and her family, I had high expectations.