Susie EvansShe won Bachelor Nation over with her chilly BachelorAlthough she was forced to depart Iceland, it wasn’t enough for her!

After Clayton Echard admitted to sleeping with the two other remaining women—Gabby WindeyAnd Rachel Recchia—Susie left him in the dust (snow?) He had to take care of the messy bits. 

Susie, however, made her triumphant comeback on the episode of March 15. But it wouldn’t have been the BachelorWithout a dramatic finale twist!

Clayton was the one who initiated the reunion. He said that he would “be willing to risk everything to speak to her again”.

Host Jesse Palmer traveled to meet Susie and asked if she’d be willing to sit down with Clayton. Despite Clayton’s parents saying they thought there was a “slim to none” chance that Susie would show up, she agreed and met Clayton—and his parents!—at his Icelandic villa.

Susie maintained her firm convictions once she and the other began to discuss it. She stated, “I was truly shocked at the way everything ended.” How did you treat me? My mentality about you was changed. “I couldn’t defend myself.” I felt so vulnerable.”