The pair reunited to have one last conversation, and let’s just say the heated chat did It is notGet warm during the cool Icelandic night. Clayton asked, “What should I do?” Clayton snapped. “I’m still fighting because I was trying to convince you, but now it’s like—”

As a tearful Susie noted that she felt “s—ty,” she shared that she wasn’t sure of a better way to go about expressing her feelings. Clayton’s response?

“I am just going to be honest with your,” he said. You just destroyed everything we have. You would be able to work with me if you truly cared about me and if I were the person you thought…

Clayton, we must not belittle the girl. Clayton was able to speak her mind.

By the end of the dramatic conversation—which included Clayton telling Susie that he didn’t know her anymore—the Bachelor escorted his former front-runner to a car.

This messy split is making us feel very confused. Would you agree? What do you think? Cast your vote below!