They are not the only ones. Some of the 5-star reviews from ecstatic Amazon shoppers: 

Customer raved, “After using Lights, Camera, Lashes By Tarte for the last year, it was time I stopped spending money on mascara. Essence Lash Princess False LASH Effect was suggested by my sister and I fell in love immediately. This mascara gives dramatic volume and length. Because of their amazing look, I find it hard to stop staring at my eyelashes every day in the mirror. It is also very durable. It doesn’t move when I take it to the gym after a long 8-hour workday. It’s a great experience!

A fan also said that the mascara was great. The mascara is amazing! The application was very easy, and the result was flawless. We would highly recommend it.

It’s $5 so I thought why not? And it works just as well, if not better than my $20 mascara! “It’s not waterproof. But I can wear it all the day at work, then go to an intense work class and it still looks amazing,” said an Amazon shopper.

One customer stated, “This mascara has become my favourite.” It lasts & doesn’t dry super fast so you can build it as much as you want. It comes off easily with my eye makeup remover & doesn’t flake throughout the day. I also love the wand (this part is huge for me) it glides the mascara on perfectly & separates my lashes.”

“I don’t write reviews until I love it or hate it. This mascara is my favorite. Mascara is my passion. I love to buy it and try different brands. “This mascara is very affordable, and it’s the best I have ever bought,” said a shopper.

Amazon customer says, “I HIGHLY recommend this, especially because the price is so low!” It is an absolute steal. It’s better than any of the high-end mascaras that I have tried, and even the ones from drug stores. “When my current mascara expires, I will be sure to buy another.