Mel looks for the silver-lining when she prepares to welcome her baby.

Watch the trailer for Season 4 Virgin RiverMel released the following July 8:Alexandra Breckenridge) is looking forward to her future as a mother—even though she doesn’t know who the father of her child is. 

Naturally, only Mark and Mark are possible choices.Daniel GilliesJack, her husband who died in a tragic accident), or William (Martin HendersonMel healed his relationship with a local bartender (called ) in season three’s finale. Jack knows there’s a chance he may not be the father, but remains supportive and excited to potentially start a family with Mel—which is why he doesn’t want to get a paternity test. Jack tells Mel that he can’t. It could alter the way that I feel about the baby if Mark is revealed to be the father.

Jack finds himself in a situation worsening when his father comes back to Virgin River. This brings up old problems and causes Jack to become addicted to alcohol. “I can’t even have a relationship to my father,” he declares. “What kinda dad will I be?”

What about the remainder of the Virgin River residents, well, it’s just as complicated.