Lopez briefly wore a simple off-the-shoulder dress for the wedding she couldn’t go through with because she was really in love with a doctor who was convinced brown M&Ms were healthy because chocolate is already that color.

But the chic look made a surprising comeback in 2018 when the Internet was convinced the custom-made Givenchy frock Meghan MarkleLopez inspired the dress that she wore in 2001’s rom-com to inspire her gown 

“I received a lot texts about Meghan Markle’s wedding gown,” said the film’s costume designer. Pam ChiltonTelled GlamourIn 2019. In 2019. But she was at a good rom-com age when the movie came out—she could have been watching it at sleepovers!”